Compare SPY, VOO and IVV
All three funds seek to provide exposure to the S&P 500, but their structures and costs are not identical.
Provider: State Street
Inception: January 1993
Structure: Unit Investment Trust
Provider: Vanguard
Inception: September 2010
Structure: ETF share class
Provider: BlackRock / iShares
Inception: May 2000
Structure: ETF
Expense ratios shown are the calculator's initial assumptions. Verify current fund documents before investing.
S&P 500 ETF Investment Calculator
Enter your investment details and customize the expense ratios and dividend yields to compare all three funds.
Investment Comparison Results
Highest Projected Portfolio Value
Based on your selected investment assumptions.
Detailed ETF Comparison
Compare projected values, investment gains, fund expenses and dividend assumptions.
| Metric | SPY | VOO | IVV |
|---|---|---|---|
| Expense ratio | 0% | 0% | 0% |
| Dividend yield assumption | 0% | 0% | 0% |
| Modeled net annual return | 0% | 0% | 0% |
| Final portfolio value | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Investment gain | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Estimated annual expense at final value | $0 | $0 | $0 |
Estimated annual expenses at final value are illustrative calculations based on the ending portfolio balance.
SPY vs VOO vs IVV Growth Chart
Compare the projected portfolio growth of the three ETFs.
ETF Expense Ratio Comparison
See how annual fund operating expenses compare.
Long-Term Impact of ETF Expenses
Compare estimated expense costs over different investment periods using your current assumptions.
| Period | SPY Expenses | VOO Expenses | IVV Expenses |
|---|
These are cumulative modeled fund expenses, not fixed charges. Actual expenses depend on changing portfolio balances and market returns.
Estimated Annual Dividend Income
Estimate annual dividend income using the selected dividend yield assumptions and projected final balances.
Dividend income is estimated using the assumed yield multiplied by the projected ending balance. It is not an actual dividend forecast.
Year-by-Year ETF Investment Growth
Examine the projected portfolio values of SPY, VOO and IVV at the end of each investment year.
| Year | Invested | SPY | VOO | IVV |
|---|
SPY vs VOO vs IVV: Which S&P 500 ETF Is Better?
SPY, VOO and IVV are three widely used exchange-traded funds designed to provide exposure to large-capitalization US stocks represented by the S&P 500 Index. Although their investment objectives are similar, they differ in fund structure, costs, trading characteristics and providers.
Investors comparing these ETFs often consider expense ratios, trading liquidity, dividend distributions, fund structure and long-term investment costs.
What Is SPY?
SPY, officially the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, is managed by State Street Investment Management. It launched in January 1993 and was the first US-listed ETF.
SPY is structured as a unit investment trust. Its expense ratio is higher than the default expense assumptions for VOO and IVV in this calculator. Its long trading history and trading activity make it particularly relevant to investors and traders who prioritize market liquidity.
Official information: State Street SPY Fund Information .
What Is VOO?
VOO is the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF. It seeks to track the performance of the S&P 500 Index and provides exposure to large US companies.
Vanguard launched VOO in September 2010. Its low expense ratio makes it a popular option among investors considering long-term S&P 500 exposure.
Official information: Vanguard VOO Fund Information .
What Is IVV?
IVV is the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF, managed by BlackRock. It seeks to track the S&P 500 Index and provides exposure to large-cap US equities.
IVV launched in May 2000 and is another widely used low-cost ETF for investors seeking S&P 500 exposure.
Official information: iShares IVV Fund Information .
SPY vs VOO vs IVV Expense Ratios
Expense ratios represent annual fund operating expenses as a percentage of assets. They are generally reflected in the fund's performance rather than billed as a separate invoice to each investor.
Using the default assumptions in this calculator:
- SPY: 0.0945% annually.
- VOO: 0.03% annually.
- IVV: 0.03% annually.
For example, on a constant $100,000 portfolio, a 0.0945% expense ratio represents approximately $94.50 in annual fund expenses, while a 0.03% expense ratio represents approximately $30.
The actual dollar expense changes with the portfolio value. Brokerage commissions, spreads, taxes and other costs are not included in these expense ratio figures.
SPY vs VOO vs IVV: Dividend Comparison
All three funds distribute dividends from their underlying stock holdings. Dividend yields change over time as company distributions and ETF market prices change.
Investors should distinguish between dividend yield, trailing distribution yield and 30-day SEC yield. These measures use different calculation methods and should not be compared as if they were identical.
The calculator allows you to enter separate dividend yield assumptions for each ETF. The projections assume dividends are reinvested as part of the modeled return.
Which ETF Is Best for Long-Term Investing?
VOO and IVV both have low published expense ratios. SPY offers a long operating history and substantial trading activity. For investors primarily seeking long-term S&P 500 exposure, the differences in expense ratios are worth examining.
However, expense ratios should not be the only factor. Investors should also consider brokerage fees, tax treatment, fund structure, trading spreads and personal investment requirements.
Is SPY Better for Trading Than VOO and IVV?
SPY is well known for its trading liquidity and extensive options market. This can be important for active traders who need to enter and exit positions frequently.
Long-term investors may place more emphasis on fund operating expenses and tracking performance. The most suitable fund depends on the investor's strategy and trading requirements.
How Does the ETF Comparison Calculator Work?
The calculator estimates the growth of an initial investment and recurring monthly contributions. It applies an annual price return assumption, dividend yield and fund expense ratio to each ETF.
(1 + Price Return + Dividend Yield) × (1 − Expense Ratio) − 1
Monthly Return:
(1 + Net Annual Return)1/12 − 1
Portfolio Growth:
Initial Investment × (1 + Monthly Return)n
+ Monthly Contribution × [((1 + Monthly Return)n − 1) / Monthly Return]
Where:
- n = total number of monthly periods.
- Price Return = assumed annual price appreciation.
- Dividend Yield = assumed annual dividend yield.
- Expense Ratio = annual fund operating expenses.
This is a simplified constant-return model. It does not simulate daily stock prices, actual dividend payment dates or historical ETF tracking errors.
Related S&P 500 Calculators
Explore more investment tools on SP500.net:
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What is the difference between SPY, VOO and IVV?
All three ETFs provide exposure to the S&P 500. Their main differences involve fund structure, expense ratios, providers and trading characteristics. SPY is a unit investment trust, while VOO and IVV have different ETF structures.
2. Is VOO cheaper than SPY?
Using the default expense assumptions in this calculator, VOO has a lower annual expense ratio than SPY. However, investors should also consider brokerage costs and trading spreads.
3. Is IVV better than VOO?
Both funds track the S&P 500 and have a default expense ratio of 0.03% in this calculator. Differences in fund administration, trading characteristics and other costs may matter depending on your circumstances.
4. Which ETF has the lowest expense ratio?
With the default assumptions used here, VOO and IVV both have a 0.03% expense ratio, compared with 0.0945% for SPY. Always verify the latest prospectuses.
5. Do SPY, VOO and IVV pay dividends?
Yes. All three funds distribute dividends from their underlying holdings. Distribution amounts and yields vary over time.
6. Can I invest in SPY, VOO and IVV every month?
Yes. Investors can make recurring purchases of these ETFs through eligible brokerage accounts. Availability of fractional shares and automated purchases depends on the broker.
7. Does a lower expense ratio guarantee higher returns?
No. Lower operating expenses can reduce investment costs, but they do not guarantee higher future returns. Market performance, tracking differences, trading costs and taxes also matter.
8. Does this calculator include dividends?
Yes. You can enter an assumed dividend yield for each ETF. The calculator treats dividends as reinvested in the projected portfolio growth.
9. Are the investment projections guaranteed?
No. The results are hypothetical mathematical projections using constant annual return assumptions. Actual market returns fluctuate and investment losses are possible.
10. Can I use this calculator with Swiss francs or euros?
Yes. Select USD, EUR, CHF or GBP to change the display currency. This changes the currency formatting only; it does not convert the underlying investment or account for exchange-rate movements.