What Are SPY and VOO?
SPY and VOO are exchange-traded funds that provide investors with exposure to large U.S. companies represented in the S&P 500 Index. Instead of purchasing individual stocks in the index, an investor can purchase shares of either ETF through a brokerage account.
Both funds aim to provide investment results corresponding to the S&P 500. Their portfolios are therefore designed around substantially similar U.S. large-cap equity exposure. However, their fees, legal structures, operational features, and trading characteristics are not identical.
What Is SPY?
SPY is the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, managed by State Street. It began trading in January 1993 and was the first U.S.-listed exchange-traded fund.
SPY seeks to provide investment results that, before expenses, generally correspond to the price and yield performance of the S&P 500 Index.
SPY is known for its large trading activity and established options market. It is used by long-term investors as well as traders who want to trade the broad U.S. large-cap market.
What Is VOO?
VOO is the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF. It was launched in September 2010 and seeks to track the performance of a benchmark index measuring the investment return of large-capitalization U.S. stocks.
VOO is frequently considered by investors seeking relatively low-cost S&P 500 exposure. Its published expense ratio in this comparison is lower than SPY's.
SPY vs VOO Expense Ratios
One of the most visible differences between SPY and VOO is the annual expense ratio. The expense ratio represents the fund's annual operating expenses as a percentage of assets. These costs are reflected in the fund's net asset value and investment performance rather than normally appearing as a separate bill to the shareholder.
Using the published figures included in this comparison:
- SPY expense ratio: 0.0945%
- VOO expense ratio: 0.03%
- Difference: 0.0645 percentage points
On a hypothetical $10,000 investment, the approximate annual expense is:
The estimated difference is $6.45 per year on a $10,000 balance before considering changes in investment value. The difference becomes more relevant as portfolio size and holding period increase.
How Small Fee Differences Compound Over Time
Investment expenses can affect long-term wealth because money paid toward fund expenses is no longer available to remain invested. The effect can compound over many years.
For example, imagine two hypothetical investments that earn the same gross return before expenses. If one investment has a higher annual expense ratio, its estimated net growth will be lower, all else being equal.
The long-term calculator above illustrates this difference. It does not assume that SPY and VOO will produce identical realized returns, but it isolates the effect of the expense ratios entered by the user.
SPY vs VOO Fund Structure
SPY and VOO have different legal and operational structures. SPY is organized as a unit investment trust, while VOO is an open-end ETF.
This distinction can affect how each fund handles cash, dividends, securities lending, and portfolio operations. The SPY trust structure has restrictions that differ from the operational flexibility available to an open-end ETF.
For example, SPY distributes dividends rather than reinvesting them inside the trust in the same way an open-end ETF may manage cash and distributions. VOO's open-end structure allows different portfolio-management and operational practices.
These structural differences are one reason the two funds can have small performance differences even though they seek exposure to the same benchmark.
SPY vs VOO Liquidity and Trading Volume
Liquidity describes how easily an investor can buy or sell an ETF without causing a substantial change in its trading price. Trading volume, bid-ask spreads, underlying asset liquidity, and the ETF creation and redemption mechanism all contribute to trading conditions.
SPY is widely used by active traders and has a particularly established options market. This can make it attractive for strategies involving short-term trading or options.
VOO is also a large and actively traded ETF. However, investors should not assume that trading volume alone determines the total cost of a transaction. Bid-ask spreads, brokerage commissions, market conditions, and order size should also be considered.
SPY vs VOO Dividends
Both ETFs receive dividend income from the companies they hold and distribute income to shareholders. Dividend distributions vary according to the dividends paid by underlying companies and the funds' distribution schedules.
SPY generally makes quarterly distributions. VOO also distributes dividends quarterly. The amount paid per share and the indicated dividend yield can change over time.
Dividend yield alone should not be used to determine which ETF is better. Investors should consider total return, which includes both changes in investment value and distributions, with the relevant reinvestment assumptions.
Does SPY or VOO Have Better Performance?
Both ETFs seek to track the S&P 500, so their long-term performance is generally expected to be similar before accounting for differences in fees and implementation.
Their actual reported returns can differ because of:
- Expense ratios and other fund operating expenses.
- Fund structure and portfolio-management practices.
- Dividend distribution and reinvestment timing.
- Tracking differences relative to the index.
- Market-price premiums or discounts relative to NAV.
- The specific dates and return methodology being compared.
When comparing performance, use equivalent time periods and the same return methodology. Compare total returns with total returns rather than comparing a price-return series with a dividend-reinvested total-return series.
Is SPY Better for Active Traders?
SPY is commonly used by active traders because of its established trading ecosystem and extensive options market. Traders may use it for intraday exposure, hedging, tactical portfolio adjustments, and options strategies.
However, the suitability of SPY depends on the strategy. Trading costs, bid-ask spreads, options liquidity, commissions, and the investor's execution requirements should be evaluated before trading.
Is VOO Better for Long-Term Investors?
VOO's lower expense ratio can be attractive to investors who want long-term exposure to the S&P 500 and do not require SPY's particular trading characteristics.
Over long holding periods, reducing recurring expenses can help preserve more of an investment's potential return. Nevertheless, a lower expense ratio does not eliminate market risk or guarantee superior future performance.
SPY vs VOO for Investors Outside the United States
Investors outside the United States should consider additional factors before purchasing either fund. These may include brokerage availability, local tax treatment, U.S. withholding taxes, estate-tax considerations, currency exposure, and the regulatory classification of U.S.-domiciled ETFs in their country of residence.
An investor whose home currency is not the U.S. dollar may experience changes in the value of their investment due to exchange-rate movements, even when the ETF's U.S.-dollar price rises.
Investors in Switzerland, the European Union, and other jurisdictions should check local regulations and applicable tax rules. A U.S.-domiciled ETF may not have the same tax or product-documentation treatment as a locally available or UCITS alternative.
SPY vs VOO: Advantages and Disadvantages
SPY – Potential Advantages
- Long operating history dating back to 1993.
- Extensive trading activity and established options market.
- Broad exposure to S&P 500 companies.
- Widely used for tactical and trading strategies.
SPY – Potential Disadvantages
- Higher expense ratio than VOO in this comparison.
- Unit investment trust structure has operational limitations.
- May be less cost-efficient for some long-term investors.
VOO – Potential Advantages
- Lower published expense ratio in this comparison.
- Open-end ETF structure.
- Broad S&P 500 exposure.
- Suitable for investors considering long-term index exposure.
VOO – Potential Disadvantages
- Shorter operating history than SPY.
- May not be the preferred instrument for every active trading strategy.
- Still carries the market risk of U.S. large-cap equities.
SPY vs VOO: Which One Should You Choose?
There is no universally correct choice. The decision depends on investment horizon, trading requirements, account type, fees, and personal circumstances.
An investor primarily focused on long-term S&P 500 exposure may find VOO's lower expense ratio appealing. An investor who values SPY's trading ecosystem or options market may prefer SPY for a particular strategy.
Before investing, compare the latest prospectuses, expense ratios, bid-ask spreads, distributions, and tax implications. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.
How to Compare SPY and VOO Properly
- Check the latest expense ratios on the fund providers' websites.
- Compare total returns over matching periods.
- Confirm whether returns include reinvested dividends.
- Review bid-ask spreads and trading costs.
- Consider the fund structures and distribution practices.
- Review your local tax and regulatory requirements.
- Choose the fund that fits your investment objectives and account.
Related S&P 500 Calculators and Tools
- ETF Expense Ratio Calculator – Estimate how fund fees affect investment growth.
- S&P 500 Investment Calculator – Estimate the future value of an investment.
- Historical Return Calculator – Explore historical investment returns.
- CAGR Calculator – Calculate compound annual growth rates.
- S&P 500 Inflation Calculator – Compare nominal and inflation-adjusted investment values.
- S&P 500 Drawdown Calculator – Calculate market declines from previous peaks.
- S&P 500 Recovery Calculator – Estimate the gain needed to recover from a loss.
- Portfolio Allocation Calculator – Explore hypothetical portfolio allocations.